I'm having the most trouble with disarming 6 people, without relaoding. I tried using dead eye, but everytime you start a new bar of it, it reloads your gun automatically. I would use the sniper rifle with 5 rounds, but I'd HAVE to reload. I got through everything else(excluding the outfit w/the game of 5 finger filet), and am stuck at this.
The 5 finger filet game just takes a lot of patience, I've beaten it before just not at the specific location the outfit requires.